Ravens Are So Smart, One Hacked This Researcher's Experiment
Researchers had to remove the bird because they were worried it’d teach the others.
Bild: Jon Sullivan/Wikimedia Commons
We're entering the Dawn of the Planet of the Ravens.
In fact, these birds are so intelligent that they're able to plan ahead for future events—something that has only been seen in humans and great apes until now—and will give up an immediately available reward to get a better one in the future. This is according to a new study published today in Science.
Ravens, along with jays and crows, belong to a family of birds called corvids, known for their intelligence: Previous studies have researched how Eurasian jays, for example, stash away food for future use, instead of eating it right away. But some have argued in the past that this food caching behaviour might be the limit of their ability to plan for the future.
Video: Can Kabadayi and Mathias Osvath. GIF: Jacob Dubé
In this study, researchers from Lund University in Sweden trained ravens to use a simple machine where they dropped a rock in a tube to earn a food reward. Later, they were put in a room with the puzzle box (but no rock), which was then removed. An hour later, the birds were presented with a row of objects: the rock, and several distractions. Nearly all of them chose the rock, and 86 percent managed to successfully use it to open the machine when it was presented to them 15 minutes later.
In another experiment, 78 percent of ravens were able to successfully barter with a human and exchange goods—trading a bottlecap for a reward—a higher success rate than what's been seen in similar experiments done with apes.
I phoned co-author Can Kabadayi, a doctoral student in cognitive science, over Skype to ask him about the new paper. (His profile photo featured two ravens perched on his head and shoulder.)
He described to me how one experiment took an eerie turn: One raven in the experiment figured out how to work their rock/box contraption first, then began teaching the method to other ravens, and finally invented its own way of doing it. Instead of dropping a rock to release a treat, the future Ruler of the Raven Kingdom constructed a layer of twigs in the tube, and pushed another stick down through the layer to force it open. The bird had to be removed from the experiment before it could teach any other birds how to do it.
Kabadayi told me it's logical for apes to have similar cognitive traits to humans—like the ability to plan for the future—because they're our closest relatives. The evolution of corvids like ravens is so distant from us that it suggests they developed this ability for their own unique reasons. "Ravens are avian dinosaurs that shared an ancestor with mammals around 320 million years ago," the Science paper notes.
"It's an independent evolution of complex cognition, which is a fascinating idea, because it shows that evolution sometimes likes to rerun good solutions. In this case, it's planning skills," Kabadayi said.
The fact that corvids have brains the size of a walnut might not be a disadvantage. A study published last year revealed that though their brains are much smaller than some apes, like the capuchin monkey, the brains of corvids and large parrots have large numbers of neurons in some parts of their brains, at high density. Kabadayi said that their connection speeds might be even faster than those of mammals due to these neurons' close proximity to one another.
"Bird brains are just bird brains, it was almost like an insult. But it should be a compliment," Kabadayi said. As for that bird who figured out how to hack the experiment, he and his colleagues nicknamed it "the little engineer."
Kabadayi told me that people are fascinated with corvids mainly because they represent some of the smartest animals we interact with on a daily basis. Sure, apes can be scary, but they're not exactly watching you walk to your car or blatantly stealing knives from a crime scene. Then it's personal.
Correction: This piece originally identified the great apes as humans' closest ancestors, when in fact they are our closest relatives. It's been updated.
Get six of our favorite Motherboard stories every day by signing up for our newsletter.