Pfc. Bradley Manning as drawn at his February 23, 2012, by USMC Sgt. Shawn Sales
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
In a way, the Baghad airstrike video, now known as the "Collateral Murder" video, is a microcosm of Manning's efforts, and, indeed, the motivation of war reporting in general. An event occurs. A government is not forthcoming. The free press attempts to investigate, filing an FOIA request, and the government responds with more self-interested secrecy.To make the free press work, and to break down this wall of secrecy, Manning took it upon himself to do the ethically right thing and release the video, allowing us all to see what the hell is happening in this war on terror. The ethical problems of the airstrike video, according to Coombs, were even acknowledged by Manning's fellow intelligence analysts. (See: United States vs. PFC Bradley Mannin, June 3 transcripts, pg. 80.)Are we, as a nation and world, to go on watching atrocities unfold, witnessing power attempt to hide from a reckoning, and remain silent? If so, what type of beings have we become? These are the type of questions Manning seems to have asked himself. And for that, he's most likely going to prison. (It's important to note that Manning has admitted that his breach of duty was illegal, although in this case military law and ethics do feel far apart.)Another thing to consider with Manning's trial is how secrecy is being piled upon more secrecy. For two years Manning was silenced as the government and his defense built their cases. Secret pre-trial hearings determined what defense evidence would be considered. The trial is not televised. There is no audio. Ironic, is it not, that Manning, who tried to ensure the press could do its job in the face of state secrecy, is being cloaked in that very same veil of secrecy.In an ideal world, Americans and the world would be able to see Manning's face in that military courtroom. They would be able to see and hear exactly what is in those published court transcripts. But just as with the Collateral Murder video, the government knows that it is far better to hide that visual narrative. Why? Out of sight is out of mind.Are we, as a nation and world, to go on watching atrocities unfold, witnessing power attempt to hide from a reckoning, and remain silent?