The Embera people of Panama have done well at keeping drug traffickers at bay. Image: Genelle Quarles/Burness Communications
Advertisement
Advertisement
Those areas—places that are “protected” but are patrolled by hired guards, military, or law enforcement instead of community leaders—are seeing the most deforestation, illegal logging, and drug smuggling. Often, just one or two guards will be in charge of covering thousands of hectares of land and won't have good backup, Davis says.What's happening, essentially, is drug traffickers are taking the path of least resistance. They could become engaged in an all-out war with indigenous people who are keen to hold onto their land and have government backing, or they could relocate to an area where there is little oversight from anyone. They nearly always choose the latter.Davis says that, when forest rights are protected, communities have legal recourses against outsiders who try to intrude. In Nicaragua, for instance, the Mayangna people have been able to call in the country’s “Green Battalion,” a government group designated to protect forest areas, to help expel drug traffickers. Without the Mayangna’s help, that group would have had little way of knowing anything was going on there.Though indigenous land rights are better protected in Central America than they are in many parts of the world, Davis says the situation could be better. In Honduras, it took more than a decade for the Garifuna people to peacefully recoup their land, and in many places, indigenous people are living without and sort of special recourse to keep outsiders off their land. That can lead to situations that are lawless at best, and overtly violent at worst. The forest's best protectors, he says, are the people who are already there."These community forests contrast very strongly with protected areas that don’t have recognized rights," he said. "Where local people do not have rights and they’re guarded by forest rangers that, in the vast majority of cases, are underfunded. Where community rights have been recognized, they've organized themselves and built strong and vibrant communities and don't want this near them."When forest rights are protected, communities have legal recourses against outsiders who try to intrude.