Motherboard

  • All
  • Film + Video
  • Music
  • Art + Design
  • Gaming
  • Environment + The Body
  • Wonderful
  • Video Room
  • Open Collections
Technology and Philosophy The Future of Music Technology in Fashion The Future of Moving Pictures Our Joysticks, Our Consoles Do-It-Yourself Tech Beyond the Internet Space In the Lab Nature Technology and Love Myths and Weirdos Meme Culture Business and Politics Animals MB 2011 Mixtape Watch This Trailer View all

Welcome to Motherboard

Collapse

Motherboard is a celebration of the diversity and eclecticism of the culture that surrounds technology. Rather than squinting at technology through the lens of gizmos and gadgetry, Motherboard explores the ways it influences and affects music, art, design, film, gaming, sports, issues surrounding the environment, and everything else we find important.

So consider the floor open for group participation. It's simple: Get involved in an existing discussion, post your own related videos, write posts, comment, anything… you're now part of the Motherboard.

Learn more about Motherboard

New to Motherboard?

Then let us get you situated! Before you know it, you’ll be:

  • Writing, editing, and posting all your wildest technological musings
  • Commenting on stories and helping to push the conversation forward
  • Creating a personalized page and chatting with other users
  • And a whole lot more…
  • Join now
  • Login

Inside Occupy Wall Street's Information War: Whose Message Is It Anyway?

Posted by Joshua_Kopstein on Monday, Oct 03, 2011

  • Save this post
  • Img_20111001_192833_584x354__large
  • Nyt_large
  • Img_20111001_185932_584x436__large
  • Next
  • Prev
Share Retweet
Add This

On Saturday, the marchers of Occupy Wall Street were cheered upon returning to Zuccotti Park, the economic justice movement’s place of indefinite residency in Manhattan’s financial district. Drums beat to a tribal soup of writhing, wet human bodies, drenched from hours of rainfall. A short time later, the mood shifted as news regarding the fate of those marchers who got held up by police on the Brooklyn Bridge trickled in.

“I have video of police officers dragging people across the street,” said one young woman to an organizer standing outside of the makeshift ‘media center.’ The small tent, cordoned off by plastic tape on all sides, is the occupation’s de facto media battlestation. From here, a fleet of plugs and power strips connect to dozens of laptops and electronic gadgets, all overloading their circuits in order to bring to light to the day’s events.

A Bridge Too Near

The day’s events were alarming. During their march across the Brooklyn Bridge, over 700 protesters were arrested en-masse after they mistakenly entered the bridge’s vehicular roadway. A live stream online surfaced as chants of “the whole world is watching!” rang out, showing police officers pulling the trapped demonstrators out of the crowd, one by one, and detaining them with plastic zip ties before loading them onto prison buses brought in from Riker’s Island.

The New York Times was on the scene, and had reported that police had allowed marchers onto the roadway, then arrested them. But then, something happened. OWS’ ragtag media team sprang into action:

Clearly something was amiss. The police chiefs were quoted saying that they had given “repeated warnings” to anyone coming onto the bridge’s vehicular roadway. But many protesters, including some that I spoke to as they emerged from the pedestrian walkway in Brooklyn, claimed that the police weren’t stopping anyone from marching on the roadway. From the vantage point of the walkway, it looked like a trap.

Before long, the Times’ swapped lede-in started making the rounds on social media sites. The undeniable edge held by the occupiers in this information war was on full display. And just as people were beginning to ponder why the police would do such a thing, Occupy Wall Street’s media network pointed to a possible answer: A very timely $4.6 million donation from JP Morgan Chase.

Late Sunday, however, the police released video of a lone officer warning protesters not to enter the bridge roadway under threat of arrest, supporting earlier claims but perhaps also raising questions on the NYPD’s inability to divert the crowd onto the pedestrian path using physical barriers.

Entering Offline Mode

The movement’s high-tech media savvy, which flourishes in the absence of complacent mainstream news giants, is counter-pointed by a low-tech charm that hearkens back to the old social justice movements of the 1960s. Numerous “mic checks,” crowd-sourced amplifications which echo back fragmented speech in lieu of microphones, allow individual messages to be communicated across a vast sea of demonstrators — with varying degrees of effectiveness.

A complex system of hand gestures attempts to bring some semblance of order to the chaos, enabling organizers to form consensus on issues (as was utilized in assembling the group’s manifesto) or simply telling a speaker to hurry up and get to the point. Most importantly, these practices do not discriminate: Anyone with something to say, no matter how poignant or inane, can express themselves to large crowds at Occupy Wall Street’s basecamp in Zuccotti Park. There is, appropriately, no sense of authoritarian leadership or cliques here. Just people.

More and more people every day, in fact. Even with the ill-fated marches on the Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges, the protest gained record numbers this weekend. But even more impressive than quantity is the notable variety of people coming by to show support: Transit workers, airline pilots and now even U.S. Marines are filling the ranks of OWS’ increasingly populous demonstrations.

Revolution.xls

Consequently, the very same openness mentioned above, and the variety of ideas and causes it allows, has been the focal point of the movement’s most derisive criticism. The mainstream media’s near-ubiquitous subtext for coverage of the events suggests confusion over the group’s demands, and whether they even have coherent message. Of course, considering the nature of the establishment-serving institutions being criticized — big media, the banks and the government — this kind of heavy-handed, empty scorn is par for the course.

And it’s not as if anyone carefully observing these protests would have any doubt as to the central message: Wall Street and the moneyed interests behind its associated culture of casino-style profiteering have hijacked the welfare of the United States, claiming record profits off the backs of millions of suffering American taxpayers who are now on the brink of financial ruin. Sure, there is the inimitable vibe of unwashed new-age hippies and fish-worshipping eco-freaks mixed in. But these small offshoots in agenda, despite claims from mainstream media, are not so obtuse as to distract from the larger overall theme: 99 percent of the country is getting ripped off.

Even so, rarely throughout history has a social movement ever materialized as a codified list of demands. As Glenn Greenwald notes in his piece defending the fledgling movement, “Personally, I think there’s substantial value even in those protests that lack “exit goals” and “messaging strategies” and the rest of the platitudes from Power Point presentations by mid-level functionaries at corporate conferences. Some injustices simply need anger and dissent expressed for its own sake, to make clear that there are citizens who are aware of it and do not accept it.”

If it’s frustration and anger that the movement needs to survive, America has got plenty to spare. But still, it might not be a bad idea to wear a polo shirt while venting all that sociopolitical angst.

Connections

  • When Occupy Wall Street Got Real
  • Rating:
  • rate 1
  • rate 2
  • rate 3
  • rate 4
  • rate 5
  • (7 ratings)4

Filed under:

  • Beyond the Internet
  • Business and Politics
  • Environment + The Body
  • occupy wall street
  • occupywallstreet
  • ows

  • Send to a friend
  • Save this post

RSS

About the author

5361519541_56035374f1_z_medium

Joshua_Kopstein

(╯‵Д′)╯彡┻━┻ (⧜⧋⧜ )||///
Brooklyn, United States
Member since 2009

Electronic musician and computer culture journalist. Contact: josh ◢at◣ motherboard ◐dot◑ tv

  • More on Joshua_Kopstein
  • View all Joshua_Kopstein's posts

Conversation Leaders

  • Profile2_theme_leader
  • Alec1_theme_leader
  • _mg_2752_theme_leader
  • Alex-pasternack_theme_leader
  • Headshot_theme_leader
  • Macface_theme_leader
  • Photo-4_theme_leader
  • 198144_10100444937463675_12400637_62766012_6835874_n_theme_leader

In the Discussions:

  • Beyond the Internet
  • Business and Politics
View all

Related Posts

  • Img_20111031_170302_sidebar (video) How To Break The Banks With Heavy Junk Mail In Three Easy Steps
  • Ows-press_sidebar After Press Blackouts, The Copupation & Re-Occupation of Zuccotti Park
  • Anonymous_sidebar (video) 2011 Was the Year of Anonymous

Blog Roll

  • Alt.Engadget
  • This Recording
  • BLDGBLOG
  • Matrixsynth
  • Mudd Up!
  • IEEE Spectrum
  • Thought Catalog
  • Devour
  • Babbage
  • Cyberology
  • Technosociology
  • Rhizome
  • Creators Project
  • VICE
  • Smithsonian
  • Atlantic Tech
  • Death and Taxes
  • BBC Horizon

Related posts

  • (video)

    Trick Banks, Treat Them With Junk Mail

    The media blitz which followed the police raids at Occupy Oakland served as a kind of memento mor... (video)

    Oct 31, 2011
    by Joshua_Kopstein
    • Save this post
    • Watch and discuss
  • Media Missed The Copupation of Wall Street

    By the time the news vans arrived in force, the morning sunlight had already caressed the corners...

    Nov 16, 2011
    by Joshua_Kopstein
    • Save this post
    • Read and discuss
  • (video)

    2011 Was the Year of Anonymous

    After their visible hesitance to prominently cover various popular uprisings around the world, it... (video)

    Dec 21, 2011
    by Joshua_Kopstein
    • Save this post
    • Watch and discuss
  • The Government Doesn't Need Laws to Censor the Internet

    Ever since last week’s historic web blackout rattled the cage in Washington, droves of lawm...

    Jan 25, 2012
    by Joshua_Kopstein
    • Save this post
    • Read and discuss
  • Q+A: OccuPints With Jerry Greenfield

    It was your classic Eleventh Hour curveball. Early this past March, in the latest of late-editing...

    May 01, 2012
    by Brian_Anderson
    • Save this post
    • Read and discuss
  • Are the Cops Getting Occupy High?

    Ask anyone in the bleary-eyed younger crowd milling around Peavey Plaza, an Occupy Minnesota hotb...

    May 04, 2012
    by Brian_Anderson
    • Save this post
    • Read and discuss
  • How Computers Helped New York Burn

    In City Limits,, David Alm reviews Joe Flood’s The Fires, about how reliance on computer mo...

    Jul 11, 2010
    by Aggregator
    • Save this post
    • Read and discuss
  • (video)

    To Grow a Healthy World, Combine the Internet With the '60s

    Remix the 60s – not its supposedly selfish hippiness but the out-of-the-box thinking part &... (video)

    Aug 12, 2010
    by Will_Han
    • Save this post
    • Watch and discuss
  • (video)

    Now Facebook is Everywhere, And Everyone is Geotagged

    Above: Facebook’s press conference announcing Places. In the run-up to Facebook’s Pla... (video)

    Aug 19, 2010
    by Alex_Pasternack
    • Save this post
    • Watch and discuss
  • To Cope With Fat Fingers, Sumo Wrestlers Turn to a Magica...

    In the wake of a number of illegal gambling charges surrounding the Japanese sport of Sumo wrestl...

    Aug 27, 2010
    by Sam_McDougle
    • Save this post
    • Read and discuss
    • Most Popular
    • Very Popular
    • Popular
    • Popular this Week
    • Most Recent
View more related

Motherboard loading...

End of transmission.

Welcome to Motherboard Explore How To More
Motherboard is a celebration of the diversity and eclecticism of the culture that surrounds technology. So consider the floor open for group participation.
  • All
  • Film + Video
  • Music
  • Art + Design
  • Gaming
  • Environment + The Body
  • Wonderful
  • Sorting content
  • Saving posts
  • What is a collection
  • How to become a leader
  • Posting content
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Vice
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Join Motherboard Watch Videos Here! Help About Motherboard
  • Subscribe to the RSS feed RSS © 2010 Vice All Rights Reserved
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site by AREA 17
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Subscribe to the RSS feed
  • Newsletter
  • Hey stranger
  • Join now
  • About MB
  • Login
  • Search Motherboard